Meet Cassidy, a young girl that considers herself unlucky and thinks she attracts misshapes. When her parents died and she blamed herself. She falls under the spell of a local Shaman “Grandfather” who promise all will be well if she marries a man with a scar on his face with the shape of a Star! She finds Dave Lerman in the Mail order brides’ ad with a star on his face and marries him for all the wrong reason!

Meet Mary, a young woman wanting to find love, but being forced into accepting marriage proposals from old, undesirable bachelors. Mary’s father is ready for her to be engaged to anyone – as long as they have a house and money to their name. In a desperate attempt to find a husband on her own terms and control her own destiny, she answers the call to head west where she meets and marries John, a veteran of the War Between the States.

Charlotte is the big sister of two rambunctious young lads, Preston and John, and the beloved daughter of her parents who is struggling dearly to make ends meet. Charlotte thinks about making the sacrifice and heading to the Wild West to help her family out as much as she can.

Meet Olivia, a young girl looking for love and marriage after the death of her parents, leaving her in the care of Aunt Beth. She’s not as beautiful as her younger sister, and she’s running out of options when she finally decides to take a risk and respond to an advertisement for marriage out west, in a place she’s never been. She marries Robert Bradford, though soon realizes that not everything is as she’d hoped.

Meet Isabelle (Belle), she’s lost her Pa, her mother is feeble, she has a 15-year-old sister, their income is flat, and eating three meals a day is a luxury. Her seamstress job income is just not enough to take care of them and their once beautiful home in Pennsylvania is already dilapidating. To give her mom a better life, she takes a leap of faith, heads out West to Montana to marry a handsome, wealthy farmer she has never met.